Skip to content

Supersymmetry Cheatsheet

This appendix collects the supersymmetry conventions used in the course. It is not a replacement for a full course on supersymmetry; it is a working reference for the points that repeatedly enter modern CFT and AdS/CFT:

superchargessupermultipletsshorteningprotected CFT dataprotected bulk fields.\text{supercharges} \quad\longrightarrow\quad \text{supermultiplets} \quad\longrightarrow\quad \text{shortening} \quad\longrightarrow\quad \text{protected CFT data} \quad\longrightarrow\quad \text{protected bulk fields}.

The guiding idea is simple. Ordinary conformal symmetry relates a primary operator to its descendants under PμP_\mu. Supersymmetry adds fermionic generators QQ that move between bosons and fermions. Superconformal symmetry adds fermionic lowering operators SS, so that shortening and BPS bounds can be understood by exactly the same radial-quantization logic as ordinary unitarity bounds.

Unless stated otherwise, this appendix uses mostly-Lorentzian notation in four dimensions. The conformal boundary of AdS5\mathrm{AdS}_5 has Lorentz group

SO(3,1)SL(2,C),SO(3,1) \simeq SL(2,\mathbb C),

so a Lorentz vector can be written as a bispinor,

xαα˙=xμσαα˙μ.x_{\alpha\dot\alpha}=x_\mu \sigma^\mu_{\alpha\dot\alpha}.

Undotted indices α,β=1,2\alpha,\beta=1,2 transform in the (12,0)(\frac12,0) representation of SL(2,C)SL(2,\mathbb C), while dotted indices α˙,β˙=1,2\dot\alpha,\dot\beta=1,2 transform in the (0,12)(0,\frac12) representation. We use antisymmetric tensors to raise and lower indices,

ψα=ϵαβψβ,ψα=ϵαβψβ,ϵ12=ϵ12=1.\psi^\alpha=\epsilon^{\alpha\beta}\psi_\beta, \qquad \psi_\alpha=\epsilon_{\alpha\beta}\psi^\beta, \qquad \epsilon^{12}=-\epsilon_{12}=1.

The complex conjugate of a left-handed Weyl spinor is right-handed:

(Qα)=Qˉα˙.(Q_\alpha)^\dagger=\bar Q_{\dot\alpha}.

In Euclidean signature, dotted and undotted spinors are independent complex spinors. This is why many supersymmetric localization and instanton computations look slightly different from Lorentzian unitarity arguments.

The minimal structural input is that the supercharges square to translations. In four-dimensional N\mathcal N-extended supersymmetry, the basic algebra without central charges is

{QαI,QˉJα˙}=2δIJσαα˙μPμ,\{Q^I_\alpha,\bar Q_{J\dot\alpha}\} = 2\delta^I{}_J\sigma^\mu_{\alpha\dot\alpha}P_\mu, {QαI,QβJ}=0,{QˉIα˙,QˉJβ˙}=0.\{Q^I_\alpha,Q^J_\beta\}=0, \qquad \{\bar Q_{I\dot\alpha},\bar Q_{J\dot\beta}\}=0.

Here I,J=1,,NI,J=1,\ldots,\mathcal N are RR-symmetry indices. The supercharges carry engineering dimension

[Q]=12,[Q]=\frac12,

because Q2PQ^2\sim P and [P]=1[P]=1.

With central charges included, the schematic form is

{QαI,QβJ}=ϵαβZIJ,\{Q^I_\alpha,Q^J_\beta\} = \epsilon_{\alpha\beta}Z^{IJ},

where ZIJ=ZJIZ^{IJ}=-Z^{JI} commutes with the Poincare generators. Central charges are crucial in massive BPS particle spectra, monopoles, dyons, and extended supersymmetric gauge theory. For local operator classification in a conformal theory, the superconformal algebra is usually more important than central extensions.

A supersymmetry multiplet is a representation generated by acting with supercharges on a state or operator. In CFT language, the best object is a superconformal primary O\mathcal O:

KμO=0,SO=0.K_\mu\mathcal O=0, \qquad S\mathcal O=0.

The ordinary conformal descendants are generated by PμP_\mu, while the supersymmetric descendants are generated by QQ:

O,QO,Q2O,,PμO,PμQO,.\mathcal O, \qquad Q\mathcal O, \qquad Q^2\mathcal O, \qquad \ldots, \qquad P_\mu\mathcal O, \qquad P_\mu Q\mathcal O, \qquad \ldots.

Since QQ is fermionic, each independent component can act at most once. A generic long multiplet therefore has many components. A shortened multiplet has fewer components because some QQ‘s annihilate the primary or create null descendants.

The basic slogan is

long multiplet=no extra annihilation by Q,\text{long multiplet} = \text{no extra annihilation by }Q, short multiplet=some Q’s annihilate the primary.\text{short multiplet} = \text{some }Q\text{'s annihilate the primary}.

Short multiplets are often protected: their dimensions and some correlation data cannot vary continuously, because a continuous change would require recombination with other multiplets.

The ordinary conformal algebra in dd dimensions contains

Pμ,Kμ,D,Mμν.P_\mu,\quad K_\mu,\quad D,\quad M_{\mu\nu}.

A superconformal algebra adds Poincare supercharges QQ, special superconformal charges SS, and an RR-symmetry algebra r\mathfrak r:

Pμ,Kμ,D,Mμν,R,Q,S.P_\mu,\quad K_\mu,\quad D,\quad M_{\mu\nu},\quad R,\quad Q,\quad S.

The most useful schematic relations are

[D,Q]=i2Q,[D,S]=i2S,[D,Q]=\frac{i}{2}Q, \qquad [D,S]=-\frac{i}{2}S, [K,Q]S,[P,S]Q,[K,Q]\sim S, \qquad [P,S]\sim Q, {Q,Qˉ}P,{S,Sˉ}K,\{Q,\bar Q\}\sim P, \qquad \{S,\bar S\}\sim K, {S,Q}D+M+R.\{S,Q\}\sim D+M+R.

The last line is the heart of BPS bounds. In radial quantization, SS is essentially the adjoint of QQ. Thus positivity of a norm such as

QO2=OSQO\|Q|\mathcal O\rangle\|^2 = \langle \mathcal O|S Q|\mathcal O\rangle

implies inequalities relating scaling dimension, spin, and RR-charges. Saturation of such an inequality means

QO=0Q|\mathcal O\rangle=0

for some component of QQ, hence shortening.

The following list is only a practical map for AdS/CFT. Precise real forms and exceptional cases matter in detailed representation theory.

DimensionBosonic conformal algebraTypical superconformal algebrasCommon holographic role
d=2d=2sl(2,R)sl(2,R)\mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb R)\oplus\mathfrak{sl}(2,\mathbb R) globallyN=(p,q)\mathcal N=(p,q) superconformal algebrasstrings, AdS3/CFT2\mathrm{AdS}_3/\mathrm{CFT}_2
d=3d=3so(3,2)\mathfrak{so}(3,2)osp(N4)\mathfrak{osp}(\mathcal N\vert 4)M2-branes, ABJM-like theories
d=4d=4so(4,2)su(2,2)\mathfrak{so}(4,2)\simeq\mathfrak{su}(2,2)su(2,2N)\mathfrak{su}(2,2\vert\mathcal N), especially psu(2,24)\mathfrak{psu}(2,2\vert4)AdS5/CFT4\mathrm{AdS}_5/\mathrm{CFT}_4
d=5d=5so(5,2)\mathfrak{so}(5,2)exceptional superconformal algebras5D SCFTs
d=6d=6so(6,2)\mathfrak{so}(6,2)osp(82N)\mathfrak{osp}(8^\ast\vert 2\mathcal N)M5-branes, (2,0)(2,0) theories

The canonical AdS/CFT example is

N=4 SYMtype IIB string theory on AdS5×S5,\mathcal N=4\ \mathrm{SYM} \quad\longleftrightarrow\quad \text{type IIB string theory on }\mathrm{AdS}_5\times S^5,

whose superconformal group is

PSU(2,24).PSU(2,2\vert4).

Its bosonic subgroup is

SO(4,2)×SO(6)R.SO(4,2)\times SO(6)_R.

The first factor is the conformal group of the boundary CFT; the second is the isometry of S5S^5.

6. Four-dimensional N=1\mathcal N=1 reference

Section titled “6. Four-dimensional N=1\mathcal N=1N=1 reference”

Many superconformal ideas are easiest to remember in N=1\mathcal N=1 language.

The RR-symmetry is U(1)RU(1)_R. A chiral primary satisfies

Qˉα˙O=0.\bar Q_{\dot\alpha}\mathcal O=0.

At a four-dimensional N=1\mathcal N=1 superconformal fixed point, a scalar chiral primary obeys

Δ=32R.\Delta=\frac32 R.

This equation is not a classical engineering statement; it is a representation-theoretic shortening condition. It is why exact RR-symmetries are so powerful in N=1\mathcal N=1 SCFTs.

The superspace coordinates are

xμ,θα,θˉα˙.x^\mu,\qquad \theta^\alpha,\qquad \bar\theta^{\dot\alpha}.

A chiral superfield Φ\Phi satisfies

Dˉα˙Φ=0.\bar D_{\dot\alpha}\Phi=0.

A superpotential deformation has the form

δS=d4xd2θW(Φ)+c.c.\delta S = \int d^4x\,d^2\theta\, W(\Phi)+\text{c.c.}

Since the action is dimensionless and [d2θ]=1[d^2\theta]=1, a superpotential term must have

Δ(W)=3\Delta(W)=3

at a conformal point. This is the supersymmetric version of marginality.

7. Four-dimensional N=2\mathcal N=2 reference

Section titled “7. Four-dimensional N=2\mathcal N=2N=2 reference”

The RR-symmetry of a four-dimensional N=2\mathcal N=2 SCFT is

SU(2)R×U(1)r.SU(2)_R\times U(1)_r.

Useful protected operator sectors include:

SectorRepresentative operatorWhy it matters
Coulomb-branch chiral operatorsEr\mathcal E_rcontrol Coulomb-branch geometry
Higgs-branch moment mapsμa\mu^aencode flavor symmetry and current multiplets
Stress-tensor multipletJ\mathcal Jcontains TμνT_{\mu\nu} and SU(2)R×U(1)rSU(2)_R\times U(1)_r currents

In N=2\mathcal N=2 theories, exactly marginal deformations sit in protected multiplets and are often related to complexified gauge couplings. This makes N=2\mathcal N=2 a useful bridge between generic SCFTs and the maximally supersymmetric N=4\mathcal N=4 theory.

8. Four-dimensional N=4\mathcal N=4 SYM field content

Section titled “8. Four-dimensional N=4\mathcal N=4N=4 SYM field content”

The N=4\mathcal N=4 vector multiplet contains:

FieldLorentz representationSU(4)RSU(4)_R representationComment
AμA_\muvector1\mathbf 1gauge field
λαA\lambda^A_\alphaleft Weyl spinor4\mathbf 4gauginos
λˉAα˙\bar\lambda_{A\dot\alpha}right Weyl spinor4ˉ\bar{\mathbf 4}conjugate gauginos
ΦAB=ΦBA\Phi^{AB}=-\Phi^{BA}scalar6\mathbf 6six real scalars

The antisymmetric scalar ΦAB\Phi^{AB} is equivalent to six real scalars ϕI\phi^I,

I=1,,6,ϕI6 of SO(6)R.I=1,\ldots,6, \qquad \phi^I\in \mathbf 6\text{ of }SO(6)_R.

The two descriptions are related by SO(6)SO(6) gamma matrices,

ΦAB=12(ΓI)ABϕI,\Phi^{AB} = \frac{1}{\sqrt2}(\Gamma_I)^{AB}\phi^I,

with a suitable reality condition. In many holographic formulas, the SO(6)SO(6) vector notation ϕI\phi^I is cleaner; in representation theory, the SU(4)RSU(4)_R notation is often cleaner.

The complexified gauge coupling is

τ=θYM2π+4πigYM2,\tau = \frac{\theta_{\rm YM}}{2\pi} + \frac{4\pi i}{g_{\rm YM}^2},

and the planar ‘t Hooft coupling is

λ=gYM2N.\lambda=g_{\rm YM}^2 N.

In the standard AdS5×S5\mathrm{AdS}_5\times S^5 normalization,

L4s4λ,gsgYM24π,\frac{L^4}{\ell_s^4}\sim \lambda, \qquad g_s\sim \frac{g_{\rm YM}^2}{4\pi},

with precise numerical factors depending on convention.

9. SU(4)RSO(6)RSU(4)_R\simeq SO(6)_R dictionary

Section titled “9. SU(4)R≃SO(6)RSU(4)_R\simeq SO(6)_RSU(4)R​≃SO(6)R​ dictionary”

Irreducible representations of SU(4)SU(4) are often labeled by Dynkin labels

[a,b,c].[a,b,c].

Some essential examples are:

RepresentationDynkin labelDimensionPhysics
fundamental[1,0,0][1,0,0]44left gauginos λA\lambda^A
anti-fundamental[0,0,1][0,0,1]4ˉ\bar 4right gauginos λˉA\bar\lambda_A
vector of SO(6)SO(6)[0,1,0][0,1,0]66scalars ϕI\phi^I
stress-tensor multiplet primary[0,2,0][0,2,0]2020'half-BPS scalar primary
half-BPS tower[0,p,0][0,p,0]variableKK scalar tower on S5S^5
singlet[0,0,0][0,0,0]11Konishi-like operators

The half-BPS single-trace scalar primaries are schematically

OpI1Ip=Tr(ϕ(I1ϕIp))traces,\mathcal O_p^{I_1\cdots I_p} = \operatorname{Tr} \left( \phi^{(I_1}\cdots \phi^{I_p)} \right) -\text{traces},

or, equivalently, using a null SO(6)SO(6) polarization YIY^I satisfying YY=0Y\cdot Y=0,

Op(x,Y)=YI1YIpTr(ϕI1(x)ϕIp(x)).\mathcal O_p(x,Y) = Y_{I_1}\cdots Y_{I_p} \operatorname{Tr} \left( \phi^{I_1}(x)\cdots\phi^{I_p}(x) \right).

They transform in

[0,p,0][0,p,0]

and obey the protected dimension formula

Δ=p.\Delta=p.

For p=2p=2, this is the bottom component of the stress-tensor multiplet. For p2p\geq 2, the corresponding supergravity modes are Kaluza—Klein harmonics on S5S^5.

10. Protected versus unprotected operators in N=4\mathcal N=4 SYM

Section titled “10. Protected versus unprotected operators in N=4\mathcal N=4N=4 SYM”

A quick classification useful for holography is:

Operator typeExampleDimension
half-BPS single traceTr(Yϕ)p\operatorname{Tr}(Y\cdot\phi)^pprotected, Δ=p\Delta=p
stress-tensor multipletTr(ϕ(IϕJ))traces\operatorname{Tr}(\phi^{(I}\phi^{J)})-\text{traces}protected, Δ=2\Delta=2
conserved currentsTμνT_{\mu\nu}, JμAJ_\mu^Aprotected by conservation
Konishi operatorTr(ϕIϕI)\operatorname{Tr}(\phi^I\phi^I)unprotected
double-trace BPS composite:OpOq::\mathcal O_p\mathcal O_q:receives 1/N1/N mixing effects
long single-trace operatorsspin-chain statesgenerally unprotected

The Konishi operator is often the first example of a long multiplet. At weak coupling it looks like a simple scalar bilinear, but its dimension is not fixed by symmetry. At strong coupling it becomes a stringy state rather than a light supergravity field.

This contrast is one of the most important lessons for AdS/CFT:

protected short multipletscontrolled supergravity/Kaluza–Klein modes,\text{protected short multiplets} \quad\leftrightarrow\quad \text{controlled supergravity/Kaluza--Klein modes}, long unprotected multipletsmassive string states or interacting bulk states.\text{long unprotected multiplets} \quad\leftrightarrow\quad \text{massive string states or interacting bulk states}.

The full N=4\mathcal N=4 shortening classification is elaborate, but the most frequently used case in AdS/CFT is the half-BPS tower

[0,p,0],Δ=p.[0,p,0], \qquad \Delta=p.

These operators are annihilated by half of the Poincare supercharges. Because the number of annihilating supercharges is maximal among nontrivial local scalar operators, they are called half-BPS.

The protected dimension Δ=p\Delta=p is not a perturbative accident. It follows from the representation theory of psu(2,24)\mathfrak{psu}(2,2\vert4). The operator cannot continuously acquire an anomalous dimension without leaving the shortened representation. But leaving the shortened representation would require recombination with other multiplets carrying compatible quantum numbers. For isolated half-BPS multiplets, this recombination is forbidden.

The bulk scalar mass follows from the AdS scalar relation

m2L2=Δ(Δ4)m^2L^2=\Delta(\Delta-4)

in AdS5\mathrm{AdS}_5. Thus a half-BPS operator with Δ=p\Delta=p maps to a scalar mode satisfying

m2L2=p(p4).m^2L^2=p(p-4).

For example,

p=2:m2L2=4,p=2: \qquad m^2L^2=-4,

which saturates the Breitenlohner—Freedman bound in AdS5\mathrm{AdS}_5.

The stress-tensor multiplet is the most important multiplet in any SCFT. In N=4\mathcal N=4 SYM, its bottom component is a half-BPS scalar in the 2020' representation,

O2IJ=Tr(ϕIϕJ)16δIJTr(ϕKϕK),\mathcal O_2^{IJ} = \operatorname{Tr}(\phi^I\phi^J) - \frac16\delta^{IJ}\operatorname{Tr}(\phi^K\phi^K),

with

Δ=2,SU(4)R representation [0,2,0].\Delta=2, \qquad SU(4)_R\text{ representation }[0,2,0].

Acting with supercharges produces the RR-symmetry currents, the supersymmetry currents, and the stress tensor:

O2 Q JμR, Sμα Q Tμνand other descendants.\mathcal O_2 \quad \xrightarrow{\ Q\ } \quad J_\mu^R,\ S_{\mu\alpha} \quad \xrightarrow{\ Q\ } \quad T_{\mu\nu} \quad \text{and other descendants}.

In AdS/CFT this single CFT multiplet packages several bulk massless fields:

Tμνgμν,JμSO(6)AμSO(6),Sμαψμα.T_{\mu\nu} \leftrightarrow g_{\mu\nu}, \qquad J_\mu^{SO(6)} \leftrightarrow A_\mu^{SO(6)}, \qquad S_{\mu\alpha} \leftrightarrow \psi_{\mu\alpha}.

13. Superconformal indices and protected counting

Section titled “13. Superconformal indices and protected counting”

A superconformal index is a trace over the Hilbert space on Sd1S^{d-1} that counts states annihilated by a chosen supercharge. Schematically,

I=TrSd1(1)Feβ{Q,Q}ixiqi.\mathcal I = \operatorname{Tr}_{S^{d-1}} (-1)^F e^{-\beta\{Q,Q^\dagger\}} \prod_i x_i^{q_i}.

Only states satisfying

{Q,Q}=0\{Q,Q^\dagger\}=0

contribute. Long multiplets cancel between bosons and fermions, while protected short multiplets can survive. Because of this cancellation, the index is invariant under continuous deformations that preserve the chosen supercharge.

The index is powerful, but it is not the full spectrum. It counts protected states with signs and fugacities; it usually cannot tell you the full degeneracy of long multiplets.

Supersymmetry gives Ward identities just like ordinary global symmetry. If QQ is conserved and the vacuum is supersymmetric,

Q0=0,Q|0\rangle=0,

then for local operators Oi\mathcal O_i,

i(1)F1++Fi1O1[Q,Oi}On=0.\left\langle \sum_i (-1)^{F_1+\cdots+F_{i-1}} \mathcal O_1\cdots [Q,\mathcal O_i\}\cdots \mathcal O_n \right\rangle =0.

Here [,}[\, ,\,\} is the graded commutator. These Ward identities relate correlators of different components in the same supermultiplet. In a superconformal theory, they strongly constrain two- and three-point functions of protected multiplets.

In AdS/CFT, these identities become relations among bulk couplings inside the same supergravity multiplet.

CFT supersymmetric objectBulk interpretation
RR-symmetry groupinternal isometry of compact space
RR-current JμaJ_\mu^abulk gauge field AμaA_\mu^a
stress-tensor multipletgraviton supermultiplet
half-BPS chiral primaryKaluza—Klein supergravity mode
long single-trace multipletmassive string state, generally
superconformal indexprotected bulk state count
conformal manifoldmoduli of AdS vacua or exactly marginal boundary conditions
Wilson line preserving SUSYfundamental string or brane ending on boundary
defect preserving SUSYbrane embedding with worldvolume AdS\mathrm{AdS} factor

The protected half-BPS tower is the cleanest bridge between N=4\mathcal N=4 SYM and type IIB supergravity:

Tr(Yϕ)pdegree p harmonic on S5.\operatorname{Tr}(Y\cdot\phi)^p \quad \longleftrightarrow \quad \text{degree }p\text{ harmonic on }S^5.

A few mistakes show up constantly.

First, do not confuse a supersymmetry multiplet with a conformal family. A supermultiplet contains several conformal primaries related by QQ. Each conformal primary then has its own PμP_\mu descendants.

Second, do not assume that a classically marginal operator is exactly marginal. Exact marginality is a statement about vanishing beta functions and operator mixing. Supersymmetry helps, but it does not make every classical marginal deformation exactly marginal.

Third, do not assume that all protected quantities are coupling independent in the same way. A BPS dimension may be fixed, while certain OPE coefficients can still depend on exactly marginal couplings unless additional nonrenormalization theorems apply.

Fourth, do not identify single-trace with protected. Many single-trace operators in N=4\mathcal N=4 SYM are long and unprotected.

Fifth, do not identify BPS with free. BPS operators exist at strong coupling and are often the best-controlled observables precisely because they are representation-theoretic, not perturbative.

Supercharges:

{QαI,QˉJα˙}=2δIJσαα˙μPμ.\{Q^I_\alpha,\bar Q_{J\dot\alpha}\} = 2\delta^I{}_J\sigma^\mu_{\alpha\dot\alpha}P_\mu.

Superconformal adjoint relation in radial quantization:

QS.Q^\dagger \sim S.

Shortening mechanism:

QO2=O{S,Q}O0.\|Q|\mathcal O\rangle\|^2 = \langle\mathcal O|\{S,Q\}|\mathcal O\rangle \geq 0.

N=1\mathcal N=1 chiral primary:

Qˉα˙O=0,Δ=32R.\bar Q_{\dot\alpha}\mathcal O=0, \qquad \Delta=\frac32 R.

N=4\mathcal N=4 half-BPS tower:

Op=Tr(Yϕ)p,Y2=0,Δ=p,[0,p,0].\mathcal O_p=\operatorname{Tr}(Y\cdot\phi)^p, \qquad Y^2=0, \qquad \Delta=p, \qquad [0,p,0].

AdS scalar relation in AdSd+1\mathrm{AdS}_{d+1}:

m2L2=Δ(Δd).m^2L^2=\Delta(\Delta-d).

For AdS5\mathrm{AdS}_5:

m2L2=Δ(Δ4).m^2L^2=\Delta(\Delta-4).

Stress-tensor normalization in four-dimensional N=4\mathcal N=4 SU(N)SU(N) SYM:

a=c=N214.a=c=\frac{N^2-1}{4}.

At large NN,

a=cN24.a=c\sim \frac{N^2}{4}.

Use the algebraic fact {Q,Qˉ}P\{Q,\bar Q\}\sim P to explain why the scaling dimension of QQ is 12\frac12.

Solution

In a conformal theory, PμP_\mu has scaling dimension 11 because it generates translations and raises the dimension of an operator by one:

[D,Pμ]=iPμ.[D,P_\mu]=iP_\mu.

The supersymmetry algebra says schematically

{Q,Qˉ}P.\{Q,\bar Q\}\sim P.

Therefore the dimension of the product QQˉQ\bar Q must be 11. Since QQ and Qˉ\bar Q have the same dimension,

[Q]+[Qˉ]=1,[Q]+[\bar Q]=1,

so

[Q]=[Qˉ]=12.[Q]=[\bar Q]=\frac12.

Equivalently, in the superconformal algebra,

[D,Q]=i2Q.[D,Q]=\frac{i}{2}Q.

Let O\mathcal O be a superconformal primary. Explain why positivity of QO2\|Q|\mathcal O\rangle\|^2 leads to BPS bounds.

Solution

In radial quantization, QQ^\dagger is proportional to a special superconformal charge SS. Therefore

QO2=OQQOOSQO.\|Q|\mathcal O\rangle\|^2 = \langle\mathcal O|Q^\dagger Q|\mathcal O\rangle \sim \langle\mathcal O|S Q|\mathcal O\rangle.

For a superconformal primary,

SO=0.S|\mathcal O\rangle=0.

Hence

SQO={S,Q}O.S Q|\mathcal O\rangle = \{S,Q\}|\mathcal O\rangle.

The anticommutator {S,Q}\{S,Q\} is a linear combination of DD, Lorentz generators, and RR-symmetry generators. Acting on a primary with definite quantum numbers, it becomes a number depending on

Δ,spin,R-charges.\Delta,\quad \text{spin},\quad R\text{-charges}.

Positivity of the norm demands that this number is nonnegative. This gives a unitarity or BPS bound. If the bound is saturated, then

QO2=0,\|Q|\mathcal O\rangle\|^2=0,

so the descendant QOQ|\mathcal O\rangle is null. The multiplet shortens.

For a half-BPS operator Op\mathcal O_p in N=4\mathcal N=4 SYM with Δ=p\Delta=p, compute the AdS5_5 scalar mass m2L2m^2L^2 for p=2,3,4p=2,3,4.

Solution

The scalar mass-dimension relation in AdS5\mathrm{AdS}_5 is

m2L2=Δ(Δ4).m^2L^2=\Delta(\Delta-4).

For the half-BPS tower,

Δ=p.\Delta=p.

Therefore

m2L2=p(p4).m^2L^2=p(p-4).

For p=2p=2,

m2L2=2(24)=4.m^2L^2=2(2-4)=-4.

For p=3p=3,

m2L2=3(34)=3.m^2L^2=3(3-4)=-3.

For p=4p=4,

m2L2=4(44)=0.m^2L^2=4(4-4)=0.

The p=2p=2 mode saturates the Breitenlohner—Freedman bound in AdS5\mathrm{AdS}_5.

Explain why the Konishi operator is not dual to a light supergravity field at strong coupling.

Solution

The Konishi operator is a singlet scalar operator schematically of the form

K=Tr(ϕIϕI).\mathcal K = \operatorname{Tr}(\phi^I\phi^I).

It is not in a protected half-BPS multiplet. It belongs to a long multiplet, so its scaling dimension is not fixed by the superconformal algebra. As the ‘t Hooft coupling λ\lambda changes, its dimension can acquire a large anomalous contribution.

In AdS/CFT, light supergravity fields correspond to single-trace operators whose dimensions remain of order one at strong coupling. Protected half-BPS operators are the canonical examples. Long unprotected operators generally become massive string states when λ\lambda is large. Thus the Konishi operator is not part of the low-energy supergravity spectrum; it is a stringy state.

Show that the stress-tensor multiplet primary of N=4\mathcal N=4 SYM is traceless in its SO(6)RSO(6)_R vector indices.

Solution

The stress-tensor multiplet primary is

O2IJ=Tr(ϕIϕJ)16δIJTr(ϕKϕK).\mathcal O_2^{IJ} = \operatorname{Tr}(\phi^I\phi^J) - \frac16\delta^{IJ}\operatorname{Tr}(\phi^K\phi^K).

Contracting with δIJ\delta^{IJ} gives

δIJO2IJ=Tr(ϕIϕI)16δIJδIJTr(ϕKϕK).\delta^{IJ}\mathcal O_2^{IJ} = \operatorname{Tr}(\phi^I\phi^I) - \frac16\delta^{IJ}\delta^{IJ}\operatorname{Tr}(\phi^K\phi^K).

Since I,J=1,,6I,J=1,\ldots,6,

δIJδIJ=6.\delta^{IJ}\delta^{IJ}=6.

Therefore

δIJO2IJ=Tr(ϕIϕI)Tr(ϕKϕK)=0.\delta^{IJ}\mathcal O_2^{IJ} = \operatorname{Tr}(\phi^I\phi^I) - \operatorname{Tr}(\phi^K\phi^K) = 0.

Thus O2IJ\mathcal O_2^{IJ} is symmetric traceless, transforming in the 2020' representation of SO(6)RSU(4)RSO(6)_R\simeq SU(4)_R.